From ‘House of the Dragon’ to ‘God of War’ to ‘The Witcher,’ shows are getting smacked by creators for seeming to stray from source material. And there are reasons it’s happening now.
Amazon Studios has to be at least a little thankful that J.R.R. Tolkien is no longer around.
First, the studio came under fire by best-selling fantasy author Brandon Sanderson for its Wheel of Time adaptation (“I had my problems with the show,” Sanderson said last year. “I won’t miss being largely ignored; they wanted my name on it for legitimacy … it had a fan base that deserved better”). Then last month, the creator of the God of War video game, David Jaffe, savaged a first-look photo (above) from Prime Video’s upcoming big-budget adaptation (“It is so bad in so many ways,” Jaffe said in a YouTube rant. “Neither of these characters look very interesting or appealing. If this was God of War: Dumb and Dumber edition, this is what you would expect”).
To be fair, Jaffe has been a critic of other God of War spinoff efforts since his involvement with the game ended nearly two decades ago, and he added that he trusts the Prime Video show’s producer Ronald D. Moore to deliver. But given all the fandom debate that surrounded Amazon’s first two seasons of its The Lord of the Rings prequel series, The Rings of Power, not having Tolkien rage-tweeting about the show’s Harfoots has to be a blessing.
Prime Video is not alone in having a fantasy creator target its adaptation. The Witcher author Andrzej Sapkowski has repeatedly thrown passive barbs at Netflix’s troubled series, saying things like the streamer “never listened to me” and “I cannot praise the show, it wouldn’t be decent” (The Witcher also famously lost its star Henry Cavill amid still-murky circumstances, with the actor having hinted that fidelity to the source material was a core issue for him).
Andrew Mayden 
Leave a comment